In light of the news today that the Warner Brothers and Paramount merger is set to go through, we are - officially! - the only ones coming to save us: this community and every leader, artist and organization inside it. How we behave in this moment really, deeply matters to the future of the ecosystem. If everyone is in it for themselves, no one will win.
So this essay is about public accountability, business practice and some tea from the frontlines of crowdfunding and indie film.
I need to start with some very boring context: Kickstarter is a Public Benefit Corporation. That means they have a charter they must abide by, and, according to their own website that charter is supposed to protect them from overreach of financial interests. They’re effectively making a declaration that the charter can come before the financial interests of the company. From the webpage about their charter:
Benefit Corporations are for-profit companies that are obligated to consider the impact of their decisions on society, not only shareholders. Radically, positive impact on society becomes part of a Benefit Corporation’s legally defined goals. When a company becomes a Benefit Corporation, it can choose to make further commitments. In our new charter (shown below) we spell out our mission, our values, and the commitments we have made to pursue them.
We will deliver a benefit statement annually that will measure the results of our efforts to promote these public benefits.
In August 2026, and presumably to accelerate Public Benefit, Kickstarter launched a $1M creator fund. I pre-empted this article with a substack note about this last week, and in that note I said I was excited about this because lord knows we need all the money we can get in this space - and that is true. Anyone willing to invest $1M to help filmmakers, theater makers, dancers, and authors accelerate their projects should be celebrated.
But I also had a bad feeling.
Because in May 2026, via text message, the CEO of Kickstarter had asked me for a third (maybe a fourth) time whether or not I was open to selling Seed&Spark. In previous conversations I was pitched an idea about how rolling up the crowdfunding space could create benefits for filmmakers. I entertained the idea for a while.
But after careful consideration, we decided that filmmakers whom we primarily serve - need to have a choice. If Seed&Spark got folded into Kickstarter, filmmakers and artists would really have only one crowdfunding platform designed to serve artists. I deeply believe the way we do things at Seed&Spark works better for filmmakers. That is evident in the fact that Seed&Spark has nearly twice the campaign success rate as Kickstarter, (80% vs around 45%) especially in the film, theater, dance and music categories.
Over the last three years as we have engaged in these conversations about acquisition, I have offered a few ideas about ways we could collaborate instead of merge to grow the overall pie in crowdfunding: we could collaborate on any one of the current playbooks that Seed&Spark has helped to spearhead (Crowdfunding, Distribution); we could join forces on the forthcoming Community Producer Playbook (which is co-written by someone who ran half a dozen of the most successful film campaigns ever on Kickstarter!) and elevate a work that would help the entire field; or we could team up with an indie awards show and create a prestigious award for best crowdfunding campaign for a film, for example, to elevate the incredible creative work it takes to do crowdfunding well. (I think this last one is really fun.)
During the text exchange in May, I resurfaced the idea of collaborating on the Community Producer Playbook but I was told they “want to explore acquisition - focus on impact rather than competition.” And, “we have some stuff up our sleeves.” Then, the Creator Fund dropped. On the surface, it’s a copy of Seed&Spark’s Patron’s Circle Fund, which we have been running since 2022, distributing micro-grants to creators already crowdfunding on the platform. With one important difference: their funds come from their balance sheet, and ours come from established creators like Mark Duplass, Jason Reitman, Nick Kroll, Emily V. Gordon and Kumail Nanjiani. Our Patrons tell us what kinds of projects they most want to accelerate and we help them do that. And then we help the creators promote their affiliation with the Patron, and so far in 2026, 100% of Patrons Circle recipients have successfully funded their projects.
But last weekend, a creator from our community forwarded an email he had received from Kickstarter:
I would learn that lots of these emails have gone out to members of our community.
Now, on their website, Kickstarter has an open application for the Culture Fund as if anyone can access the funds. And maybe some of the funds are being used that way. But they’re also individually emailing creators who have already demonstrated crowdfunding aptitude on Seed&Spark and offering them money to move to Kickstarter. In some cases, they’re offering thousands of dollars. And listen, if someone offers you $5K, I want you to have it! But let’s be clear: this is money that Kickstarter makes back out of fees. So if they offer $5,000 to a project that raises $100K, it’s a wash for Kickstarter. This is marketing money disguised as grants.
I suppose it’s flattering that they’re spending so much money to compete with us. And what they’re offering as “special services” to creators are things we offer standard to every creator on our platform.
But they make 40x our revenue, mostly from tech and gaming projects. Their Creator Fund is equivalent to our entire annual budget.
I’m a first-time founder and a woman, which means raising capital has always been a massive challenge. We’ve raised like maybe 1/15 or 1/20th of what Kickstarter has raised. So instead, over the last 15 years, we pursued community strategies to grow the business: we have partnered with film festivals, arts schools, non-profits and activist organizations, and we have traveled to about 30-50 cities a year to offer workshops for free. Our goal has always been to build for the margins, to create tools, resources and systems that can work just as well for you in Macon, Georgia, as they do in New York City. In fact, I spent so much time traveling the Southeast and learning the challenges that are faced here specifically - generational impacts of red-lining, systemic racism, classism, lack of public arts funding - that I moved here. I live 30 minutes east of Atlanta, in a sleepy suburb but a beautiful community. And creators live out there, too, to have good public schools for their kids, diverse neighborhoods and affordable prices. But it’s like, really far from the rooms where it happens. In the Southeast, creators have become wildly entrepreneurial to make up for the lack of infrastructure.
And I live here because I know if we can build tools that work for creators who have faced every conceivable barrier, those tools will work well for everyone.
That’s why we offer all our workshops for free, why we partner with non-profits to reach their communities, and why all the educational resources we offer are public and not behind a paywall. Because if we are ever going to build a truly independent, sustainable ecosystem, it will take all of us working together. And education should not be a barrier to participation.
So when I discovered that Kickstarter was taking their $1M creator fund and spending it as competitive marketing capital, I was…honestly just so bummed out.
Only a few months earlier, the CEO had texted me a warning that IndieGoGo was personally reaching out to creators on other platforms to lure them away. “Don’t underestimate these guys,” he wrote to me. “They are relentless.”
“I hope this intel helps, I genuinely believe S&S is a good thing in the film industry.” And then I found out only a few months later that the Kickstarter team was doing the exact same thing.
This felt out of alignment with what I thought I knew about the company. I went and read Kickstarter’s own charter, searching for answers.
And there it was, two lines right at the beginning of their charter:
Kickstarter will care for the health of its ecosystem and integrity of its systems.
Kickstarter will engage beyond its walls with the greater issues and conversations affecting artists and creators.
So with $1M dollars to put towards creators, Kickstarter chose to come after the smallest company in the space and carve off customers like slices of pie, rather than using that money to grow the pie.
But there is so much more powerful ecosystem building they could be doing with this money, if they have it to spare.
I’m calling this out because in our independent artist space, leaders and companies should be accountable for their ecosystem impact. As arts support organizations, just doing capitalism will not improve the landscape.
And I would like them to engage this conversation, because it affects artists and creators beyond its walls.
And the truth is, if Kickstarter is successful at this strategy, they could potentially put us out of business. It may be obvious, but specialized crowdfunding is a very low-margin business. My biggest concern is that putting us out of business was their intention all along. In the last couple of years, Seed&Spark has been sending 50-150% more money to independent filmmakers every month because of our high campaign success rate. I know this because Kickstarter used to publish all their stats for community transparency. That page is no longer available on their website, taken down sometime in the last year. It’s a drop in the bucket for their larger revenue, but a blow to their reputation, as the leading platform for artists. Most of their revenue is made from new tech products (a stat I also learned from their now defunct page).
I have been on the ground in the independent film space for 15 years not just as Seed&Spark’s founder, but as a filmmaker using my own product (four campaigns and counting!): and I can say with conviction pushing Seed&Spark out of the ecosystem is not a benefit.
So while we don’t have $1M in free cash, here’s what we have that Kickstarter does not:
The highest campaign success rate in the world (80% vs their 45%)
The Patrons Circle Fund - These are small grants made actually out of the kindness of their hearts by big talents like Mark Duplass, Jason Reitman, Ray Romano, Nick Kroll and many more
We don’t charge platform fees! So any money you get from your campaign or our Patrons Circle goes directly into your pocket and does not just circle back to our bottom line.
Personalized feedback for every project that comes to Seed&Spark, not just for the select few
Office hours twice a month for creators to connect with our crowdfunding experts
Free resources like the Crowdfunding and Distribution Playbooks that we keep updated
The Independence Partnership with Kinema that guarantees high-quality platform distribution for every film that successfully funds on Seed&Spark
We teach free workshops on career sustainability (funding, pitching distribution and more) seedandspark.com/events and we do these a lot outside major film markets where creators most need the resourcing.
We offer crowdfunding rallies with amazing partners like Goldhouse and Open Television. In addition to raising money and gathering an audiencegathering audience for your project, you can win mentorships, cash and additional distribution.
And if you think we’ve created a lot of free resources, community gatherings and coordinated campaigns before, I honestly CANNOT WAIT for October when I can share the next big phase of our community resources. We are only 6 full time and 2 part time folks, so what we lack in speed we make up for in heart!
I want filmmakers to have a choice. A healthy ecosystem comes from specialization, not vertical integration. Vertical integration is the Big Tech playbook: own the space and every part of the pipeline, make the most money for your shareholders and WIN. But that’s not the promise of Kickstarter’s Charter. If they want to lead in ethical business practices, they need to be accountable to the integrity of the ecosystem they claim to care for.
When creators can choose the best platform for themselves and their projects, I know that will not always be Seed&Spark.
But we are certainly trying to earn your business, not buy it off you.
Maybe I am naive and the forces of capitalism are too great to contend with, but I deeply believe that if in this moment we work in solidarity rather than competition, if we can be accountable to one another, there are enough of us to build something new and better, together.


I’m so glad you wrote this. Very insightful. KS taking their metrics down speaks volumes. I think you are right to speak out.
Oh, my hear breaks from that level of betrayal towards someone I deeply respect (you, in case that isn't clear).
And while you promote choice, for anyone who EVER asks me, there's only ever one choice. S&S. You have a better deal, with better perks. KS can pander to the ignorant, but you offer by FAR the best... for filmmakers.
I believe in you, Emily. I know you're a fighter, but don't lose heart. I believe in you!