What We Mean When We Say “Politics”
Everything has become “politics” today. Just ask anyone who…works a job, or has kids, or has a body that requires healthcare, or wants to make art. For most of us, the act of existing has become “political.” The word has been so colonized by ideology that we’ve forgotten its root: how we organize ourselves with each other. In fact, there are so many things that we used to call “community” — making art, sharing resources, protecting our neighbors, protecting our environment, protecting the thriving of children — that are now referred to as “politics.” It’s exhausting.
And what a lot of people are doing right now is switching off the news, shutting down so as not to feel burned out. Putting their heads down and working on their own stuff. Scraping to get by.
Here’s the provocation: what if the most “political” act (by which I mean community act) available to us as a creative industry right now is to care? Not the also-colonized “self-care,” which if you’re not careful, can just be a way to stick your head in the sand. Care as an orientation. A way of moving through the world that shapes every step you take in your creative journey. It shows up in how you make work. It shows up in how you receive it.
If we are to understand politics as the jockeying for power, care says: we all have the power.
The Paradigm We’re Trapped In: The Culture of Scarcity
Capitalism is the water we’re all swimming in: an economic system where private individuals or companies own resources and businesses compete with each other and are driven by supply and demand. There is nothing innately human or socially beneficial inherent in Capitalism. And yet it is the driving force of American society and government. We’re in it. We’re all steeped in it whether we want to or not. It’s the Studio model that hides the truth behind “Hollywood accounting.” It’s the Big Tech model that puts profits over people and works to extract every last ounce of productivity. (I give you: the new device that lets you hack your dreams and work while you sleep!)
This shapes our behavior as independent creators even when we don’t endorse it: we compete with people we’d otherwise call collaborators, we protect what we’ve built instead of sharing what we’ve learned. There are scant few seats in those Sundance Labs. It’s deeply competitive to get into top film schools. And you see this in the nonprofit space all the time: equally noble organizations competing for the same $50,000 grant because that’s how funders with ample resources have decided to distribute them.
After reading Ruha Benjamin’s Imagination: A Manifesto, I started to become acutely aware of all the ways in which the scarcity paradigm doesn’t allow us the imagination to picture what we actually want — it can only generate variations of what already exists. Hence why philanthropy works just like the rest of capitalism. Hence why a lot of indie film has tried to operate like mini Hollywood.
And as I was grappling with this, my friend and co-conspirator Coraline Ada Ehmke introduced me to the concept of used futures: when we try to imagine a different world using the paradigm and tools built to maintain this one.
One of the most pernicious “used futures” in film is pick-me culture. Pick-me culture is the idea that if you just work hard enough and are special enough, the powers that be will recognize it and you will become one of the Specials. Hollywood thrives on this (and so do the wildly evil folks who know they can get what they want from the young and impressionable in exchange for access to power). We all know there are still creators building out their fancy “distribution plan” slides in their pitch deck with the plan to get picked by Sundance and get picked by a distributor - which is more statistically unlikely at this point than winning the actual lottery. We cannot build a new framework while we believe someone else will build our distribution strategies and capabilities. We have to believe that is for us to decide.
We could instead be pushing one another to get to the best idea because we have agreed that everyone will benefit from the solution. If accumulating wealth is the only metric, that’s the only solution that gets picked.
The system that I and so many of my peers have been craving and building towards is one in which doing the work we love is sustainable, audiences are in real relationship with our work, communities form around meaning rather than transaction. We want generational impact built out of a commitment that all of us can and should thrive together. We can barely imagine it because we are so steeped in the scarcity paradigm. But we feel the gap every time we “win” something that doesn’t feel like winning. How many films got into Sundance this year are still waiting for a distributor? How many took alternative deals that probably broke their hearts to sign? How many will just resign themselves to never finding an audience for their work because deep down they believe if they weren’t picked, they didn’t deserve it?
There is no power in this paradigm for individuals. Any attempts to shift it are written off as “too idealistic” or as “cottage industry.” Y’all - the number of times I was patted on the head in the early years of Seed&Spark, told that my idealism was sweet but it just isn’t how the business works.
To the current paradigm, care looks cute.
Care as Orientation
An orientation is something you practice: it shapes what you notice, how you enter a room, what you do before the agenda begins, how you hold each other as humans.
Care is pre-political in the best sense: it happens person-to-person before it ever becomes policy or platform. Its foundational ethic is simple and uncompromising: until it’s not harmful to any of us, it’s not beneficial to any of us. That is not idealism. It’s a different operating logic. That means we focus on solving short term problems in ways that do not create long term harm, and that we make different choices about how we build things with generational thriving in mind.
Compare that to Effective Altruism, the favorite way to be nice in Silicon Valley, which built an entire ethos around “doing the most good for the most people” — an optimization framework that says you can earn money doing whatever it takes as long as you use that money effectively. But their definition of efficacy prioritizes global cause areas (e.g., global health, climate adaptation) that may not align with the most pressing local needs. Their focus on cost-effectiveness often overlooks equity, justice, and context-specific solutions, which are critical in Africa’s development challenges, so the Effective Altruists most ignore the entire continent. That is what happens when you try to institutionalize ethics without the orientation of care. You end up with a system that can justify harm to real people in service of a hypothetical greater good. (And not for nothing, the most prominent Effective Altruists keep ending up in prison.)
Care refuses that trade-off. It insists that the person in front of you and their specific challenges are not an externality.
Care also isn’t some Pollyanna orientation. It doesn’t require perfect agreement. It requires presence and accountability to each other’s humanity — including when that’s inconvenient, including when you’re tired, including when there’s an agenda to get through. It means being willing to let things take longer, building at the speed of trust.
What Care Actually Looks Like
First and foremost, care looks like mutual aid. Actively knowing whether the basic needs of your collaborators are met as pre-condition for moving forward into the work. You cannot seek the best long term solutions when you’re hungry or you’re worried about paying rent. You cannot make meaningful work from a place of desperation. We all have, but is that really the system we want to keep building? If we do not invest in mutual aid, then our attempts to build for long-term thriving will always be labeled idealistic.
Care looks like transparency. Sharing what you’ve learned even when it cost you to learn it. Mentoring peers, not just proteges. Kicking open doors and making sure people come through with you. As former Lionsgate executive and production company founder Kamala Avila-Salmon said at a panel recently, we believe that if there can be gate-keeping, there can be gate-opening. This turn of phrase is a gift, and care is way in which everyone can participate in gate-opening.
Transparency is the entire principle behind the open-culture education we’ve been building like The Crowdfunding Playbook and The Distribution Playbook. Our entire industry improves faster the sooner everyone knows that information. We can offer a comprehensive guide of lessons already learned *for free* and update the playbook the market develops, new mistakes are made and shared, and new innovations surface from them.
Care looks like pausing. Before the meeting begins, before the agenda runs, you check in: are the humans in this room okay? Nobody wants to spend more time on zoom, I get it. (I regularly have 10-14 zoom meetings per day.) It makes us want to get to the point. But pausing when the new face pops up to see how someone is showing up before diving in is a gentle refusal to treat people as functions of their productivity.
I moderate panels all the time, and I noticed a massive shift when I started applying this pausing live on stage. At the beginning, I ask that we take a breath together as an entire room. I ask the attendees to check in with themselves, and we check in with each panelist: how are you showing up today, and what are you holding? It’s a simple reminder that the people in the audience are not just consumers and the folks on the panel are full humans, not just their functional role as experts. It creates a warmth and trust that allows for more transparency and even deeper conversations.
Care looks like genuine curiosity about your so-called competitors...and building real relationships. If we want to get to the best solutions for long term, we have to know what others in our field are building and how, and find the seams where collaboration is possible. Care is choosing to build with rather than build against — because when you do, you both build more, and you create less redundancy in a world that cannot afford it. This requires a lot of trust.
We used to have a distribution arm at Seed&Spark. In fact, we’ve tried so many things over the years - TVOD (2012), FAST (2014), aggregation (2015), streaming (2016), live non-theatrical (2019). Lordy we invested so many resources trying to find the thing that could support long term sustainability. What we are indisputably the best at, and have been for most of those years is crowdfunding. So when I saw what was being built at Kinema, I thought…there it is. They’ve cracked something. So rather than trying to build a competitor, we passed off our streaming business to our dear friends at Indieflix, and slowly started working on understanding how to partner with Kinema. We spent time evaluating all the ways in which we could grow one another’s businesses as a benefit to creators, even if it means potentially giving up long-term upside for each company that could come from replicating what’s already there. But that partnership grew out of a real friendship with Christie, a deep trust that both she held a lot of care for me and my well being and a lot of care for the community we serve. Now we work in lockstep, and we can already see the benefits across the board.
And at scale, care becomes solidarity. Solidarity is a structural commitment to each other’s success as a condition of your own. In fields with small audiences and big barriers, redundancy kills everyone. Collaboration creates abundance. Even if solidarity costs you something, care requires it — because the alternative, winner-takes-all in a shrinking extractive field, is not actually winning. Because who is left to enjoy it?
Structurally, this looks like: sharing resources instead of hoarding them even looking for ways to seek resources alongside your competitors; checking your own ego or desire to be the one who cracked the code in service of collective good; calling-in instead of calling-out, and being accountable to one another; honoring different theories of change (as long as they don’t cause harm); actively seeking deep knowledge of the field and its players, always looking for collaboration opportunities. And it fundamentally means investing deeply in trust and leaving behind a purely transactional “I give, you give” framework.
We have a small interpersonal practice we encourage at all Seed&Spark events to build muscle of care and solidarity:
At the end of the event, Instead, our instruction is to meet two people you don’t know, and share with one another your big, hairy audacious goals for your creative career. Make an ask and an offer, but not of the same person — we ask everyone to push back against transactional “networking.” Instead the challenge is to trust that if everyone in the room makes an ask and an offer, everyone will get what they need.
See also: The Solidarity House at Sundance
Why Care Is Missing from Our Politics
Our political discourse, even about how the entertainment business is run, has become so much about policy and systems that we have lost the person-to-person substrate that makes those systems legible, livable and enjoyable.
We’ve outsourced care to institutions (nonprofits, government programs, HR departments, apps) and then wondered why it doesn’t feel like care. Care cannot be institutionalized at scale without losing its essential requirement: knowing the person in front of you, and being genuinely concerned about the outcomes they face.
We click “like” on an Instagram post about our friend’s new song release instead of listening deeply and sending genuine warm feedback. We rely on Uber rather than taking our friends to the airport. These are small acts that save time and inconvenience to anyone. But these acts, sold to us as convenience, have demolished industries, destroyed unions, underpaid workers, and funded authoritarianism. The externalities are real; we’ve just agreed not to look at them. (We just click I AGREE and even though it doesn’t say so explicitly, we agree to let Apple profit from child labor in cobalt mines.)
We all watch on Netflix and listen on Spotify, platforms which have systematically upended the entire entertainment industry, and then wonder why the independent platforms that would actually pay us better royalties aren’t growing faster.
This isn’t an argument against systems. We know we need solutions that can scale to a certain degree. But we have enough evidence now that systems without care at their foundation will always reproduce harm. Which is why caring hard — hard enough as a filmmaker to change your own viewing behavior, to sign up, read and share the newsletter, to support platforms that have care built into their foundation — is not optional sentimentality. It’s infrastructure.
Building new infrastructure has a cost. That cost is convenience.
Care is a Discipline of Keeping Your Power
When you practice care, you audit your most automatic thoughts and habits at the root: Is this a habit that’s convenient, or is this really just “how things are done”? Could there be another way? Can I expect others to change how they do things if I don’t change how I do them? Am I actually really waiting to get picked?
Inside our current system you can completely justify self-protection; to want to put your head down and just get what you can. It doesn’t often seem like there is another option. There are billion dollar PR campaigns to make us think that the version of technological progress being sold by Silicon Valley is inevitable as opposed to a series of very strong choices being made by a very few people. If you find yourself feeling that these outcomes are inevitable is when you know you have ceded your agency.
So what can one person do, really?
Care. Care can change the operating conditions, if we choose it. When we choose to share what we’ve learned, what audiences we’ve built, the partnerships we hold, it allows the people around us to grow faster. When we choose to change our own viewing behavior in order to build up the new platforms with care at their core, everyone stands to benefit. When we choose to make work that expresses our deep care for our audiences and communities, that’s what will get them to follow us to those new platforms as well. When we stop looking at who we might be competing with and instead look at who we can be building and growing with, we have entered a new paradigm. And when we care it makes it easier for others to care, too.
Sometimes we fail. We proceed without checking in and step over someone who is suffering. We protect information and prevent someone from making a mistake they could have avoided. We compete when we could have collaborated because we wanted to feel the surge of victory. The discipline is returning to some core questions:
Am I competing, or am I growing collaboration?
Who could I bring with me right now?
What would I do here if I weren’t afraid there wasn’t enough?
Who am I leaving behind by moving this fast?
What’s the generous move — and what’s stopping me from making it?
What am I choosing — and what am I pretending isn’t a choice?
And that’s where we can find our collective power.

Emily such a big yes to all of this. It's going into my reference library. I need to keep going back to this
Love the point about convenience!